Stripe vs PayPal, priced on your own mix
The headline rates are 2.9% and 3.49% — and neither is what a cross-border store pays. Add the international surcharge and FX, and the gap changes direction depending on your average order value.
Result
Every calculation runs locally. Nothing you type is sent anywhere — check the network tab.
Every comparison of Stripe and PayPal starts with 2.9% + 30¢ versus 3.49% + 49¢. That comparison is for domestic US card payments, which is not what a cross-border store processes.
Add Stripe's international surcharge on foreign-issued cards, and PayPal's higher cross-border commercial rate, and the ranking can flip — particularly at low average order values, where fixed fees dominate.
This calculator prices both on your actual order value, cross-border share and FX. It is a cost model, not a recommendation: chargeback handling, payout speed and conversion rate all matter more than a few basis points.
How it is calculated
stripe % = domestic rate + (international surcharge × cross-border share) + FX stripe fee = AOV × stripe % + fixed fee paypal fee = AOV × (commercial rate + FX) + fixed fee difference = |paypal fee − stripe fee| × monthly orders
Reading the result
- The surcharge is the whole argument — Stripe adds roughly 1.5% on cards issued abroad; PayPal's cross-border commercial rate starts around 4.4%. On a mostly-international store, that difference dwarfs the 0.6% headline gap.
- FX applies to both — but not equally — If you price in USD and settle in USD, the FX line is zero for both. If you settle in EUR or GBP, add the conversion spread you actually see on statements, not the published 1%.
- Check the gap per order, not per month — A monthly difference is easy to dismiss. Divide by order count: a $0.48 per-order gap on 800 orders is $384 a month — and it compounds at every volume increase.
2026 benchmarks
| Metric | Typical range | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Stripe — US card | 2.9% + $0.30 | Domestic baseline. |
| Stripe — international card | +1.5% | On top of the base rate. |
| Stripe — currency conversion | +1% | When the charge currency differs from settlement. |
| PayPal — domestic commercial | 3.49% + $0.49 | US-to-US transactions. |
| PayPal — cross-border commercial | ≈4.4% + fixed | Depends on the receiving country. |
| Break-even AOV | $30–$60 | Below this, fixed fees decide the winner. |
Indicative 2026 published rates. Negotiated pricing is common above $100k/month.
Questions
Why does the winner change with order value?
Do I have to pick one?
What about chargebacks and holds?
Where does Wise or Airwallex fit?
Rates reflect published 2026 pricing for US-based merchants. Cross-border surcharges vary by card issuing country and are negotiated at volume.
Next calculator
Break-even ROAS & profit
One number that tells you the lowest return on ad spend you can survive — carrying product cost, freight, payment fees and returns.
TikTok Shop take-home
Referral fee, creator commission and payment costs stacked on one order, so you see what actually lands in your account.